Whom Would You Rather Have?

RW Shane Doan
COYOTES
Winnipeg 's first-round selection in the 1995 entry draft, the 6'2", 228-pound power forward recently signed a multiyear contract. He averaged .33 goals per game over the past two seasons and had scored three goals this season through Sunday.

RW Brad Isbister
ISLANDERS
Winnipeg 's third-round selection in the 1995 entry draft, the 6'4", 230-pound power forward was dealt to the Islanders in March 1999. He averaged .35 goals per game over the past two seasons and had scored two goals this year through Sunday.

THE VERDICT: Isbister has a harder edge to his game, but Doan is more durable and disciplined, and therefore is our choice.